Speed-to-lead research

The first business to reply usually wins. Here's what the research actually shows.

The two studies everyone quotes, what they measured, where they don't fit a trades business, and why the window for a homeowner with a leak is shorter still.

What speed-to-lead means

Speed-to-lead is the time between a customer's first attempt to contact you and your first reply. Research measures it from one of two starting points: a web enquiry landing, or a phone call reaching your number.

They behave differently. Someone who has just filled in your quote form has their phone in hand and expects a reply. Someone whose call has just gone to voicemail is already looking for the next number.

Most published research measures web form leads at B2B software and insurance firms in the US, not calls to trades businesses. The data is solid, but a homeowner with no heating is in a very different position from someone booking a software demo. We point out that gap wherever it matters below.

The key findings

The foundation is the 2007 Lead Response Management study by InsideSales.com and MIT, led by Dr James Oldroyd. It analysed over 100,000 call records and contact attempts across six companies. Firms that contacted a web lead within five minutes were 100 times more likely to reach that person than firms that waited 30 minutes. It also found most businesses gave up after one or two attempts, while contact chances weren't largely used up until around six.

The 2011 Harvard Business Review article "The Short Life of Online Sales Leads" by Oldroyd, Kristina McElheran and David Elkington audited 2,241 US companies. Those that contacted a lead within an hour were nearly 7 times more likely to qualify it than those that waited longer, and more than 60 times more likely than those that waited 24 hours or more.

  • Within 5 minutes vs 30 minutes: 100x more likely to reach the prospect (InsideSales.com / MIT LRM study, Oldroyd, 2007)
  • Within 1 hour vs later: nearly 7x more likely to qualify the lead (HBR, Oldroyd, McElheran & Elkington, 2011)
  • Within 1 hour vs 24 hours or more: over 60x more likely to qualify (HBR, 2011)
  • Contact attempts before chances run out: about 6. Most businesses stop at 2 (LRM study, 2007)

How businesses actually perform

The HBR researchers didn't ask companies how fast they replied. They sent enquiries and timed the answers, which removes the flattering self-reporting you get in surveys.

Of the 2,241 US companies audited, 37% replied within an hour, 16% within one to 24 hours, 24% took longer than 24 hours and 23% never replied at all. The average first response among those that did reply was 42 hours.

Nearly one business in four paid to generate a lead and never followed it up once. And these were firms with sales staff and CRM systems. A sole trader in the van, with no one in the office during the busiest hours, starts from a harder position.

How quickly a lead goes cold

The drop-off isn't gentle. Here's the shape the research describes:

0 to 5 minutes: the best chance you'll get. They've just called or submitted the form and haven't rung anyone else yet.

5 to 30 minutes: already much lower. They've moved on to the next search result. If their call went to voicemail, they've very likely rung someone else.

30 minutes to 1 hour: every extra minute eats into the advantage fast responders have.

1 to 24 hours: the 60x gap in the HBR data sits here. It's also where many trades businesses operate: ringing back when they finish the job they're on.

Over 24 hours: this is a cold call, not a follow-up. They've booked someone or stopped looking.

One honest note: these figures are about reaching and qualifying a lead, not jobs won. Your price, availability and reputation still matter once you're talking. Speed gets you into the conversation; it doesn't win it on its own.

Which channel gets back to them fastest

Text. CTIA, the US wireless industry body, reports an open rate of around 98% for text messages, with replies typically in about 90 seconds (US data). That's why missed-call text back, a text sent the moment a call goes unanswered, is the fastest way back into the conversation.

Live phone call. The best channel when it connects. The trouble is that a callback from an unknown number often goes to voicemail, which is the delay the research is measuring.

Email. Average open rates sit around 20–25% (Mailchimp), with replies in hours. It's fine for quotes and reminders, not for reaching someone who needs an electrician this afternoon.

For missed calls, the sequence the data supports is an instant text. For web enquiries, an instant text plus a call attempt within five minutes.

Why the window is shorter in the trades

The studies are B2B. Trades enquiries put more pressure on every factor that closes the window.

The need is urgent. Someone with no heating in January or water through the ceiling has a problem happening now. Ring back six hours later and someone else has already been paid.

Loyalty is thin. Many homeowners can't name the plumber they used last time. They search, look at the top few results and ring whoever picks up.

People ring round. With an urgent job, homeowners often call two or three businesses and book the first one that answers. Reviews and price matter at the margin; speed decides who gets the conversation.

The gaps are built in. One person doing the job and answering the phone, a van on the road, an office that shuts at 5pm. A good share of calls also arrive outside working hours, when the clock starts the moment the call hits voicemail. See missed call rates for how often that happens.

Our practical take: treat the five-minute figure as the slowest acceptable reply, not a target. For a phone call, the reply needs to be a live answer or an instant text. Our guide to speed to lead for trades covers how to set that up, and the response time benchmarks give targets by channel.

Sources

Lead Response Management Study. Oldroyd, J.B. (2007). InsideSales.com and MIT. Analysis of 100,000+ call and lead records. Download PDF

"The Short Life of Online Sales Leads." Oldroyd, J.B., McElheran, K. & Elkington, D. (March 2011). Harvard Business Review. External audit of 2,241 US companies. hbr.org

CTIA, The Wireless Association. US data on SMS open and engagement rates. ctia.org

Mailchimp. Email marketing benchmarks. mailchimp.com

The LRM and HBR studies cover B2B web form leads at US technology and insurance firms. They give directional guidance for UK trades, not sector proof. More figures are on our statistics hub.

Frequently asked

What is a good lead response time?

Under five minutes is the benchmark from the Lead Response Management study (InsideSales.com and MIT, 2007), which found a 100x difference in contact rates between five and 30 minutes. For a trades business, good means answering live, or texting back within seconds of a missed call.

Does the 5-minute rule apply to phone calls?

The original study measured web form leads, not calls. Phone calls have a shorter window, because someone who rang you is actively searching right now. Treat five minutes as the slowest acceptable reply for a call, and aim for instant.

How fast should a plumber or heating engineer respond?

Immediately. For calls, that's a live answer or an automatic text the moment a call is missed. For web enquiries, an automatic text and a call attempt within five minutes. Homeowners with urgent problems often book the first business that replies.

How many times should I try to reach a lead?

The LRM study found contact chances were largely used up at around six attempts, while most businesses stopped at two. Spread them across text and phone over a few days.

How much does slow response cost a trades business?

It depends on your volume and job values. If you miss 10 calls a week and a few were emergency boiler repairs at £150 to £400 or leak call-outs at £100 to £250, that work goes to whoever answered. One new boiler enquiry can be £2,500 to £4,500 on its own. Try the missed-call revenue calculator for your own figure.

Is this research from the UK?

No. Both main studies used US B2B companies, and the text data is from the US too. The direction of the findings fits trades well, and the urgency of trades work probably makes the window shorter, but the exact multipliers aren't a measurement of UK trades.

Is text or a callback better after a missed call?

Text first. It's read quickly and doesn't depend on them picking up an unknown number. Then call. Many businesses use missed-call text back to send that first text automatically.

Be the business they find, then the one that answers

Your free AI Visibility Report scores how you show up on Google and in AI assistants, out of 100, and lists what to fix. No card needed.